Brokering Icon

Company News

B100 Research is the premier provider of renewable fuel consulting.

888.428.5617

Already a member? Login here!

Not yet? Check out member benefits!

RIN Fraud Fallout

By Reiter Scientific Consulting | Company News | 13 2012

The End of Biodiesel’s Innocence

Upon departure from the 2012 National Biodiesel Conference in Orlando, I couldn’t help but be flooded with mixed emotions.  For the better part of the last 5 years, our company has specialized in helping small (<5M GPY) biodiesel producers get off the ground by offering technical expertise, engineering guidance, and hands on assistance.  While the 2012 NBB Conference did allow us to strengthen our ties to our existing clients and brokerage partners we couldn’t help but feel concern regarding the negative impact that the recently announced RIN fraud could have on many of the companies that we have had the privilege of help get off the ground in the past 5 years.

The Best of Times

Fiscal year 2011 was nothing short of spectacular for most Biodiesel producers.  With a $1 per gallon IRS tax credit in place, and D4 RIN values exceeding $2 per gallon for much of the year, it seemed the biodiesel industry (powered by more than $3 per gallon in government incentives) had proven itself as a worthwhile (and relatively low risk) investment.  Despite record high feedstock prices (yellow grease reached an all time high of nearly $3.50 in many markets) margins held strong due in part to strong demand (and the rusulting high prices) associated with Biodiesel.  Neat Biodiesel (B100) regularly traded upward of $5 per gallon creating strong margins for existing producers and a strong incentive for new producers to enter the market.  I’ll be the first to admit, it couldn’t stay this easy (and profitable) forever.

The Foreshock

At the same time that biodiesel companies nationwide were posting record profits, a storm of fraud was brewing behind the scenes that is only now being seen on the horizon.  In October 2011, the U.S. EPA charged Maryland-based Clean Green Fuels LLC and Texas-based Absolute Fuels LLC with fraudulently creating and selling invalid RINs.  Early estimates indicated the monetary value of this fraud to be well into the millions of dollars.  Renewable Identification Numbers (RINs) are the EPA conceived method of subsidizing the renewable fuel industry.  When a company produces renewable fuel, they in turn producer RINs which via various means must be attained by the Petroleum Companies in order to satisfy their Renewable Fuel Standard (RFS) obligations.

The announcement of the RIN fraud led nearly immediately to catastrophic industry wide fall out.  With the validity of RINs now put into question, the Obligated Parties (the petroleum industry) now had a very strong justification for no longer purchasing RINs from small biofuel producers.  Their reasoning being that it was just too difficult to verify the integrity of the RINs and thus they were putting themselves at great risk by purchasing these RINs from brokers who aggregate the RINs produced by smaller biofuel producers.

The Aftershock

With rumors of RIN fraud percolating through the industry, the immediate reaction was…confusion.  On the one hand, the EPA’s stance that the Obligated Parties would need to replace the “falsified RINs” with legitimate RINs led some to believe that there would be a near term increase in RIN values.  This “supply/demand” based theory did indeed prove to be correct.  What few people suspected, was that only a select few would benefit from this “new normal.”

In short order, a 2-tier RIN system emerged where small producers would be offered only a fraction of the true-value of their RINs while the major producers continued to be able to sell their “trusted” RINs at even higher prices.  The bottom line?  Due to no fault of their own, small biofuel producers now find themself at a competitive disadvantage to large producers who make the same exact product and (in many cases) at slightly lower cost.

The Worse of Times

A 2-tier RIN market cannot last forever.  If “realized” RIN values continue to fall, small producers will be forced to compete against larger producers on an uneven playing field.  Sad as this is, this is the BEST CASE NEAR-TERM SCENARIO.  Over time, margin improvement for the major producers coupled with margin deterioration for the smaller producers could change the landscape entirely.  Already, major fuel marketer and blenders have ceased to purchase fuel entirely from many small producers.  To quote an unnamed source at the NBB show, “Half of these guys will go out of business this year.  They are walking around, not even realizing how big of a deal this RIN scandal is.”

What can be done?  Well, I asked this question directly to the EPA.  Unfortunately, their “answer” left me more disheartened than before I asked the question.

Do you have an idea as to how this situation can be resolved?  Email it to kristof@reiterscientific.  The best submissions will be discussed in further posts.

 

online games

juegos gratis

games online

free games

math games

free online games

addicting games

cool math games

cooking games

armor games

online game

pc games

pc game

racing games

funny games

maths games

girl games

game free

barbie games

primary games

shooting games

football games

fun games

maze game

kids games

games to play

truck games

scary maze game

puzzle games

fish games

hidden object games

game boy

party games

play games

fighting games

sonic games

spongebob games

addictinggames

zombie games

cartoon network games

mini clip

car racing games

motorbike games

cool games

y8 games

horse games

disney channel games

typing games

games for free

games free online

board games

mobile games

nick jr games

helicopter games

kissing games

soccer games

driving games

make up games

football game

makeover games

pool games

games car

spiderman games

fashion games

android games

miniclips

1000 games

dirt bike games

super mario games

car game

mario game

monster truck games

car parking games

pbs kids games

games play

star wars games

cars games

batman games

baby shower games

sniper games

christmas games

play game

brain games

hunting games

mini games

nickelodeon games

princess games

scooby doo games

monkey games

simulation games

chess game

pacman game

train games

power rangers games

dog games

sports games

building games

dressup games

fishing games

educational games

bubble game

naruto games

bratz games

ninja games

chess games

killing games

girl game

cartoon games

army games

transformers games

game online free

baseball games

y3 games

good games

tetris game

shooter games

boy games

scary games

barbie cooking games

game center

pet games

hot games

crazy monkey games

mario games online

school games

free phone games

adventure games online

3ds games

iron man games

game of thrones

art games

web games

pokemon

jeux de

mahjong

jugar

juegos de mario bros

tetris

rpg

minijuegos

juegos de motos

juegosjuegos

juegos de carros

juegos friv

juegos de barbie

juegos de futbol

friv juegos

jogos de tiro

juegos juegos

juegos online

juegos de chicas

juegos de autos

juegos de guerra

juegos de cocinar

free game

juegos para pc

juegos de carreras

guegos

pokemon online

juegos de peluqueria

juegos de pintar

les jeux

juegos de dora

juegos de friv

juegos de sonic

juegos de disney

jeux de guerre

juegos de villar

juegos de matar

juegos de amor

jogo da fille gratuit

juegos infantiles

descargar juegos gratis

juegos de princesas

juegos en linea

juegos de tiros

juegos para niños

juegos de patinetas

juegos de cartoon network

jeux de foot

juego gratis

jeux flash

jugar gratis

juegos de moda

juegos de cosina

juegos de bebes

juegos de coches

juegos mario

jegos de accion

juegos de estrategia

jeux de barbie

jeux de coiffure

juegos de mario bros gratis

juegos de rompecabezas

jeux de filles

juegos 10

juegos gratis de mario bros

jogos de fuerra

juego de cocina

jogo de tiro

juegos de disparos

juegos de animales

juegos gratis online

juegos para vestir

juegos de pelea

juegos de aventuras

jeux de dora

juegos para chicas

juegos de aventura

jeux jeux

browsergames

barbie juegos

juegos de mesa

mini juegos

juegos online gratis

moorhuhn

juegos divertidos

juegos para pc gratis

jeux mario

jeux de sonic

juegos de cartas

taringa juegos

juegos barbie

jeux jeux jeux

juego online

jeux de tir

jogos de gta

juegos para pintar

juegos de futbol 2011

juegos sangrientos

juegos de niñeras

juegos disney

juegos educativos

juegos para descargar

browser games

juegos de barbie para vestir

juegos nuevos

juego de barbie

juegos de vestir muñecas

jeux de chevaux

juegos de niños

jeux de camion

jeu de cuisine

juegos de cocina gratis

jeux de parking

kinderspiele

juegos para adultos

jeux moto

jeux fille

puzzle online

juegos de barbi

jeux de combat

jeux gratuit en ligne

juegos de armas

18 oyunlar

juegos didacticos

jeux gratuits en ligne

jeux de maquillage

télécharger jeux

juegos de disney channel

juegos on line

jeu de mario

juegos de juegos

jeux de naruto

dora jeux

jeux pour fille

jeux en ligne gratuit

juegos de matematicas

juegos en linea gratis

descargar juegos gratis para pc

mini jeux

jeux voiture

jeux de garçon

juegos de vestir gratis

jeux de dragon

jugar juegos gratis

giochi di super mario

juegos para jugar

jeux de football

juegos de bestir

star wars online

jeux dora

juegos de carros gratis

jogos gratis online

telecharger des jeux

jeux sonic

juegos infantiles gratis

juegos de muñecas

jeux enfants

oyunlar 1

3d oyunlari

mmorpg

araba oyunları

3d oyunlar

barbie oyunları

okey oyna

savaş oyunları

2 kişilik oyunlar

oyun kuzusu

güzel oyunlar

motor oyunları

en güzel oyunlar

araba oyunu

silah oyunları

dövüş oyunları

macera oyunları

futbol oyunları

kanal d oyunları

çocuk oyunları

oyunlar 100

oyunlar oyna

tır oyunları

yeni oyunlar

bütün oyunlar

savaş oyunu

3d oyun

strateji oyunları

bedava oyunlar

friv oyunları

3d araba oyunları

uçak oyunları

bedava oyun

erkek oyunları

oyunlar indir

okey oyunu oyna

en yeni oyunlar

zombi oyunları

araba oyunları oyna

flash oyun

jogos online

jogar

jogos de vestir

jogos de moto

jogos de carros

jogos de futebol

sinuca

papa jogos

o jogo

jogos de corrida

baixar jogos

jogos de motos

jogos da polly

jogos de luta

jogo de moto

jogos para celular

jogos de moda

jogos de cozinhar

jogos de pintar

jogos de sinuca

jogo do mario

jogos do sonic

jogos de mario

jogos do ben10

jogo da barbie

jogar jogos

baixar jogo

jogo de futebol

jogo online

jogos de carro

clik jogos

jogos de menina

jogos on

jogo de sinuca

download de jogos

jogos da dora

jogos on line

jogos de guerra

jogos da monica

download jogos

jogos de aventura

gta online

jogos 3d

jogos de fazenda

jogos de barbie

jogos de skate

jogos educativos

jogo de carros

1001 jogos

jogos de motas

jogi

jogo de corrida

jogos da disney

jogo da polly

jogos santa casa

sinuca online

jogar gta

jogos do dia

jogos de bicicleta

jogos de terror

jogos 10

jogo de luta

jogos mortais

jogos mario

jogo de carro

friv jogos

jogos infantil

jogos do naruto

jogos do homem aranha

jogos do super mario

jogos de motocross

jogos para celular gratis

jogos da pucca

jogos barbie

jogar online

jogos10

jogos de tiros

barbie jogos

quero jogar

jogos de cavalos

jogos do iguinho

jogo do flamengo

jogos oline

jogos de meninos

jogo gta

jogos xbox

jogo da velha

jogos para baixar

jogo do labirinto

jogos ben10

jogos de matematica

jogo do sonic

iguinho jogos

jogos de animais

jogo da memoria

jogos de bilhar

1000 jogos

jogos de raciocinio

jogo do corinthians

jogos do avatar

jogos de cartas

jogos do batman

jogos de corridas

baixa jogos

jogos friv

jogos de carros 3d

jogo do ben10

jogos de sonic

jogos do gta

jogos de xbox

sinuca gratis

jogos de ben10

jogos de dama

jogar guitar hero

jogos legais

giochi gratis

giochi di

flash games

giochi per ragazze

giochi online

giochi gratis online

giochi di cucina

giocare

gioca

i giochi

giochi per bambini

giochi gratis per ragazze

il gioco

giochi online gratis

giochi di calcio

scaricare giochi

giochi flash

gioco gratis

giochi di guerra

giochi di moto

gioco digitale

giochi calcio

gioci

giochi di macchine

gioco online

tutti i giochi

giochi xbox

parco giochi

giochi super mario

giochi per pc

giochi di mario

giochi di ragazze

giochi di spongebob

1001 giochi

giochi di moda

permainan

permainan barbie

permainan online

games permainan

permainan memasak

memasak

permainan game

permainan perempuan

permainan bola

permainan berpakaian

permainan anak

permainan sepak bola

spelen

speeleiland

games online free

spela

rpg games

free games download

free games online

pokemon games

spellen

free online game

monopoly online

spelle

online rpg

play online games

mmorpg games

online free games

online games free

onlinegames

speel

mmo games

spelletje

online game free

internet games

online multiplayer games

gratis spelletjes

best online games

speletjes

kinderspelletjes

olympische spelen

jetztspielen

kostenlos spielen

online spielen

spiele kostenlos

online spiele

spiele affe

spieleaffe

spiele

spiele online

spiele spielen

spielen kostenlos

gratis spiele

spiele download

affen spiele

mario spiele

rtl spiele

barbie spiele

onlinespiele

kostenlos online spielen

online spiele kostenlos

online spielen kostenlos

игры онлайн

игры для девочек

скачать игры

igra

онлайн игры

бесплатные игры

флеш игры

игры бесплатно

игры для детей

игры для мальчиков

игры на телефон

игры онлайн бесплатно

игры гонки

игры винкс

бесплатно игры

игры скачать

игры для девушек

онлайн игра

мини игры

играть в игры

детские игры

игры барби

играть в игру

игра онлайн

flash игры

игры стрелялки

игры для двоих

винкс игры

игры на компьютер

igri online

игры играть

флеш игры онлайн

торрент игры

компьютерные игры

игры одевалки

онлайн игры бесплатно

логические игры

игры на нокиа

игра шарики

игры алавар

бесплатные онлайн игры

игры спанч боб

играть онлайн

играть бесплатно

ігри для

стрелялки

ігри онлайн

гонки онлайн

онлайн ігри

العاب

العاب فلاش

jeux de

jeu

jeu de

jeux gratuits

jeux de fille

jeuxvideo

jeux gratuit

jouer

jeux de moto

jeux de voiture

jeux de cuisine

des jeux

jeux de mario

gratuit en ligne

jeu gratuit

jeux en

jeu de fille

jeux pc

jeu de moto

jeux d habillage

jeu de voiture

jeu en ligne

al3ab

jeu de guerre

le jeux

jeux d amour

jeux de course

jeux de moto cross

tout les jeux

jeu flash

jeux de voiture gratuit

jeux xbox

jeux d aventure

jeux de cartes

jeux d enfants

jeux barbie

juex

jeu de foot

jeux de guerre gratuit

tous les jeux

jeux virtuel

jeux de habillage

jeux pc gratuit

jeux de moto gratuit

jeux concours

jeux de cheval

barbie jeux

jeux de ferme

jeux de société

jeux billard

jeux online

لعبة

العاب تلبيس

تحميل لعبة

العب

لعاب

ألعاب

hguhf

العاب ماريو

العاب قص شعر

لعبة من سيربح

العاب اطفال

العاب دورا

الالعاب

العاب اكشن

العاب شمس

العا ب

العاب ذكاء

لعبة ماريو

لعبة تلبيس

العاب مغامرات

لعبة زوما

العاب السيارات

العاب كرة قدم

لعبة كراش

العاب حرب

لعبة حرب

االعاب

العاب دراجات

لعبة المزرعة

لعبة بلياردو

لعبة جاتا

لعبة كرة

تنزيل العاب

موقع العاب

تنزيل لعبة

سباق سيارات

العاب سيارات 2011

لعبة سيارات

لعبت

العاب كرة القدم

لعبة سباق

العاب اولاد

لعبة طبخ

لعبة فيفا

لعبة كونكر

العاب 2011

لعبة صبايا

لعبة البحث

لعبة الحب

游戏

7k7k

4399小游戏

遊戲

网页

小游戏

游戏下载

flash game

游戏大全

小游戏大全

网页游戏

网络游戏

游戏网

手机游戏

相关游戏

游戏排行

游戏大厅

web game

开始游戏

游戏交易平台

单机游戏

游戏排行榜

单机游戏下载

游戏介绍

游戏中心

webgame

2144小游戏

成人小游戏

西西游戏网

4399游戏

游戏免费

手机游戏下载

33666小游戏

游戏免费下载

360游戏

بازی کامپیوتر

بازی کامپیوتری

بازی

Paixnidia

παιχνίδι

παιχνίδια

arcade games

friv games

y8 new games

play free games

1001 games

paixnidia gia koritsia

kizi games

pexnidia

ゲーム

脱出ゲーム

無料ゲーム

ゲーム 無料

オンラインゲーム

pcゲーム

タイピングゲーム

ゲーム ランキング

ng searches

juego de vestir

juego 10

juego de motos

juego de mario

juego mario bros

mario bros

juego mario

mario

juego juego

juego juegos

juegos

juegos de

juegos de vestir

descargar juegos

juego

juegos de cocina

choi game

game vui

game thoi

trò chơi

tro choi dua

tro choi ban

game viet

choi tro

choi tro choi

2 Responses to "RIN Fraud Fallout"

  1. Biotom

    Permanently cancel the licenses of offending producers! They will bend over backwards to protect their bottom line.

  2. Kristof Reiter

    Strengths of the current RFS Program:

    Market Based approach (floating RIN value) to incentevise production.

    Weakness of the current RFS Program:

    Shared impact of fraud. RIN buyer is left liable for damages caused by unscrupulous RIN Producers.
    All RIN Producers are affected by fraud perpetrated by any individual.

    If we identify the strengths and weaknesses of the current system, perhaps we can devise a better system. The EPA says that they will listen to suggestions. I will personally present the ideas discussed on this thread to the EPA.

    Let’s hear your thoughts.

Leave a Reply